1931 Buffalo Nickels

Last Updated: Jul 23, 2023

Looking for the perfect addition to your 1931 Buffalo Nickels collection? Look no further than our selection of 1931 Buffalo Nickels from all over the world.

Our selection of 1931 Buffalo Nickels is the perfect place to begin your search. We have compiled a comprehensive list of collectibles from hundreds of trusted sellers, making it easy to find exactly what you are looking for.

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.
1931 S Buffalo Nickel #K6725 Cover

1931 S Buffalo Nickel #K6725

1931 SBuffalo Nickel.
Platform Logo $238.00
1931-S MS65, Buffalo Nickle, PCGS 21493857 Cover

1931-S MS65, Buffalo Nickle, PCGS 21493857

The seller is located in Mililani and has a 100.0% positive feedback rate.
Platform Logo $450.00
1931-S 5C INDIAN-HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NEAR GEM PCGS MS 64 RARITY R2 HIGH GRADES Cover

1931-S 5C INDIAN-HEAD BUFFALO NICKEL NEAR GEM PCGS MS 64 RARITY R2 HIGH GRADES

LOOK--->1931-S SHINY-LUSTROUS BUFFALO 5C SELECT-BU PCGS MS-64 CONDITIONAL-RARITY-R2(<5001-Total). We encourage you to double-check that information independently as populations and price guides are subject to change.
Platform Logo $299.95
1931-S Buffalo Nickel, LUSTROUS Beautiful (PREMIUM GEM BRILLIANT UNCIRCULATED #2 Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel, LUSTROUS Beautiful (PREMIUM GEM BRILLIANT UNCIRCULATED #2

LUSTROUS "1931-S" BUFFALO NICKEL (Choice GEM BRILLIANT UNCIRCULATED) with a Fantastic BOLD Strike & Beautiful Mint Luster! This LUSTROUS "1931-S" (Choice GEM BRILLIANT UNCIRCULATED) BUFFALO NICKEL IS THE "18th Year of Issue" for the entire BUFFALO NICKEL series, 1913 to 1938. This LUSTROUS 1931-S (Choice GEM BRILLIANT UNCIRCULATED) Buffalo Nickels comes out of a FULL roll of 1931-S Buffalo Nickels. This LUSTROUS "1931-S" (Choice GEM BRILLIANT UNCIRCULATED) with a BOLD Strike & Georgeous Mint Luster BUFFALO NICKEL has a mintage of ONLY "1,200,000" & is ready for YOUR Purchase Today!.
Platform Logo $149.95
1931 S Buffalo Nickel VF -Better Date! Cover

1931 S Buffalo Nickel VF -Better Date!

1931 S Buffalo Nickel VF -Better Date!. As always, use the photos provided and determine grade, condition, and any designations (if applicable) for yourself. If you’d like additional photos please ask. We’d be more than happy to combine shipping so let us know if you’re getting multiple items and we can combine them. And if you have any questions at all, ask.
Platform Logo $20.00
1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL Cover

1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL

Our Conditions.
Platform Logo $54.00
1931-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS-63 - Lightly Toned! Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS-63 - Lightly Toned!

Here's a 1931-S Buffalo Nickel that graded MS-63 at PCGS with light toning for your consideration!
Platform Logo $137.49
1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5C Key Date Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5C Key Date

Platinum & Palladium. Gold Eagles / Buffalo. Copper Coins. Silver Eagles. Now in his fourth decade as a Professional Numismatist, his experience includes eight years at NGC as Executive Vice President and a Grading Finalizer.
Platform Logo $11.95
1931 S Buffalo Nickel Q6073 Cover

1931 S Buffalo Nickel Q6073

Uffalo Nickel.
Platform Logo $88.00
Uncirculated 1931 S Key Date Indian Head Buffalo Nickel BU Choice UNC 1 Coin Lot Cover

Uncirculated 1931 S Key Date Indian Head Buffalo Nickel BU Choice UNC 1 Coin Lot

You will receive ONE Brilliant Uncirculated 1931 S Key Date Buffalo Nickel chosen at complete random. An iconic and must have coin for any collection!
Platform Logo $199.85
1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5 Cents NGC XF 40 Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5 Cents NGC XF 40

Grade: NGC XF 40.
Platform Logo $51.99
FULL ROLL (40 COINS) FULL DATE BUFFALO NICKELS ~ 722-3 Cover

FULL ROLL (40 COINS) FULL DATE BUFFALO NICKELS ~ 722-3

THESE COINS ARE MAINLY FROM THE THIRTYS, THUS IN THE BEST CONDITION.
Platform Logo $31.95
1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL INDIAN HEAD TYPE II Cover

1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL INDIAN HEAD TYPE II

This dispute will be closed within 48 Hours after being opened and the item will be re-listed. We try to provide the most accurate and detailed information about every item listed. We do recycle.
Platform Logo $5.00
1931-S Buffalo Nickel - NGC MS-65 - Mint State 65 Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel - NGC MS-65 - Mint State 65

It is graded by NGC as MS-65. You will receive the the coin in the pictures. Mint: San Francisco. Weight: 5g. The rate varies by state. 1967 South Africa Rand - PCGS PR-67 - Blazing Colors. Order Total.
Platform Logo $375.00
(ITM-4881) 1931-S Buffalo Nickel ~ XF+ / EF+ Condition ~ SHIPS FREE! Cover

(ITM-4881) 1931-S Buffalo Nickel ~ XF+ / EF+ Condition ~ SHIPS FREE!

1931-S Buffalo Nickel in XF+ C. Your patronage is greatly appreciated; and, so too is your honest critique. It is organized to help you find EXACTLY what you are looking for ! Placing Your Order .
Platform Logo $44.62
1931-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS (CAC) Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS (CAC)

11061 Winners Circle. L & C Enterprises, Dept E.
Platform Logo $454.00
1931 S Buffalo Nickel Choice AU Near BU....................Lot 9863 Cover

1931 S Buffalo Nickel Choice AU Near BU....................Lot 9863

You are buying the coin in the photos.
Platform Logo $44.95
BETTER DATE NO PROBLEM & ORIGINAL 1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL NICE COIN Cover

BETTER DATE NO PROBLEM & ORIGINAL 1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL NICE COIN

BUFFALO NICKEL. BETTER DATE. NO PROBLEM & ORIGINAL.
Platform Logo $17.00
1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5c NCG MS 64 Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5c NCG MS 64

Almost fully struck. The photos do not do this piece justice. Fully struck all around the edge with only the high point of the buffalo shoulder and the hair above the braid weak in detail. Great eye appeal!
Platform Logo $185.00
1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL VG/FINE NN Cover

1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL VG/FINE NN

1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL. F and J Coins.
Platform Logo $13.59
1931 S Buffalo Nickel PCGS AU 53 Cover

1931 S Buffalo Nickel PCGS AU 53

1931 S Buffalo Nickel PCGS AU 53. Gold Shield with True View.Photos are of actual coin you will receive.Thanks for looking.
Platform Logo $85.99
1931S Buffalo Nickel F Cover

1931S Buffalo Nickel F

1931S Buffalo Nickel F. Attractive better date coin with sharp hair detail and 2/3 horn on buffalo. Pleasing color. Please add $1.49 shipping.34F
Platform Logo $15.99
1931 S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel 5 Cent Piece VF Very Fine 5c US Coin Cover

1931 S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel 5 Cent Piece VF Very Fine 5c US Coin

A genuine 1931 S 5c Indian Head Buffalo Nickel in VF Very Fine Condition. Denomination 5C. Coin Type Buffalo. Grade Very Fine. Mint Mark S. Three Cents. Small Cents. Paper Money: US.
Platform Logo $32.95
#2 nicer "Fine++" low mintage 1931 S Buffalo Head Nickel Cover

#2 nicer "Fine++" low mintage 1931 S Buffalo Head Nickel

The seller is located in Woodburn and has a 100.0% positive feedback rate.
Platform Logo $18.00
1931 S Buffalo Nickel - NGC MS65 - Free Shipping Cover

1931 S Buffalo Nickel - NGC MS65 - Free Shipping

1931 S Buffalo Nickel - NGC MS65 - Free Shipping
Platform Logo $290.00
1931 S Buffalo Nickel Q6800 Cover

1931 S Buffalo Nickel Q6800

Uffalo Nickel.
Platform Logo $20.00
1931-S Buffalo Nickel Great Deals From The Executive Coin Company Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel Great Deals From The Executive Coin Company

Any coin or currency removed from its original holder is considered sold. Sealed Mint products must remain sealed and in good condition. A: Grading is a subjective opinion that is based on knowledge and experience in the industry.
Platform Logo $31.00
1931-S Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Mint USA 5c - Key Date Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Mint USA 5c - Key Date

1931-S Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Mint USA 5c - Key Date - Coin Shown Ships
Platform Logo $23.00
(ITM-4842) 1931-S Buffalo Nickel ~ XF+ / EF+ Condition ~ SHIPS FREE! Cover

(ITM-4842) 1931-S Buffalo Nickel ~ XF+ / EF+ Condition ~ SHIPS FREE!

1931-S Buffalo Nickel in XF+ C. Your patronage is greatly appreciated; and, so too is your honest critique. It is organized to help you find EXACTLY what you are looking for ! Placing Your Order .
Platform Logo $42.08
1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5c, PCGS MS 66 - Gem BU, PQ+++ Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5c, PCGS MS 66 - Gem BU, PQ+++

Gem BU, PQ+++. Reverse:Buffalo Standing on a Mound. Recessed five cents. The Buffalo nickel, also known as the Bison head or Indian nickel was struck for 25 years from 1913 to 1938. It remains one of the most iconic designs in U.S. numismatics.
Platform Logo $749.99
1931 s Buffalo Head Nickel, beautiful high grade unc. original Nickel Cover

1931 s Buffalo Head Nickel, beautiful high grade unc. original Nickel

You will receive the coin pictured.
Platform Logo $119.00
1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-802 AU55 PCGS Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-802 AU55 PCGS

11061 Winners Circle. L & C Enterprises, Dept E.
Platform Logo $204.00
1931-S 5C Buffalo Nickel (75025) Cover

1931-S 5C Buffalo Nickel (75025)

The seller is located in Ashburn and has a 100.0% positive feedback rate.
Platform Logo $19.99
1931 S Buffalo Nickel VF, Better Date Cover

1931 S Buffalo Nickel VF, Better Date

1931 S Buffalo Nickel VF, Better Date - scratch reverse 
Platform Logo $19.00
Lot of 2 Buffalo Nickel 5c 1920D Good & 1931S Fine 230778 Cover

Lot of 2 Buffalo Nickel 5c 1920D Good & 1931S Fine 230778

1920D Good & 1931S Fine. Lot of 2 Buffalo Nickel 5c. They set the price and collect all the fees. I use my 50+ yrs experience.
Platform Logo $19.99
1931 S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel Estate Find Cover

1931 S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel Estate Find

1931 S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel Estate Find. Very fine condition. See the pictures for an accurate description. If you have questions please ask before bidding.
Platform Logo $12.50
1931 S BUFFALO NICKEL IN XF CONDITION, BETTER DATE Cover

1931 S BUFFALO NICKEL IN XF CONDITION, BETTER DATE

1931 S BUFFALO NICKEL IN XF CONDITION, BETTER DATE.
Platform Logo $27.00
Original Sharp Date 1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5¢ FREE SHIPPING!! JK80IS Cover

Original Sharp Date 1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5¢ FREE SHIPPING!! JK80IS

SWEETWATERCOIN is a leading provider of nice collectible coins. Coins removed from their original holders are considered.
Platform Logo $37.95
1931-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS

11061 Winners Circle. L & C Enterprises, Dept E.
Platform Logo $354.00
1931-S/S Buffalo Nickel RPM 1 Choice BU+ Uncertified #938 Cover

1931-S/S Buffalo Nickel RPM 1 Choice BU+ Uncertified #938

Uncertified coins: Photos of uncertified single coins are of the actual coin being sold.
Platform Logo $254.00
1931 S Buffalo Nickel XF Cover

1931 S Buffalo Nickel XF

1931 S Buffalo Nickel, Extra Fine condition.
Platform Logo $35.00
1931S BUFFALO NICKEL 5 CENTS SAN FRANCISCO MINT USA NICE GRADE! Cover

1931S BUFFALO NICKEL 5 CENTS SAN FRANCISCO MINT USA NICE GRADE!

The seller has a 100.0% positive feedback rate.
Platform Logo $17.03
1931-S Buffalo Nickel - Great Date in Series - Good Appearance and Details!! Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel - Great Date in Series - Good Appearance and Details!!

This is a 1931-S San Francisco Buffalo Nickel (#DSW1-119) with a very good appearance and super detail. This is a great date in the series to acquire. There are a couple of scratches on its obverse.
Platform Logo $12.00
1931-S Buffalo Nickel Key Date Higher Grade Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel Key Date Higher Grade

1931-S Buffalo Nickel. VF+ details. Near FULL HORN.
Platform Logo $27.99
1931 S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65 Certified 5c Cover

1931 S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65 Certified 5c

The seller is located in Maumee and has a 100.0% positive feedback rate.
Platform Logo $299.95
1931-S Buffalo Nickel - Uncirculated - *Key Date* Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel - Uncirculated - *Key Date*

1931-S Buffalo Nickel - Uncirculated - *Key Date*.
Platform Logo $120.00
1931-S Buffalo Nickel - NGC MS64 (48019-L) Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel - NGC MS64 (48019-L)

Tue & Fri 10am-2pm Central. Mon, Wed & Thur 10am-5:30pm Central.
Platform Logo $219.00
1931-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS-65 Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS-65

The seller is located in Columbia and has a 100.0% positive feedback rate.
Platform Logo $291.50
1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5c -Raw- Raw Ungraded Coin, AU Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5c -Raw- Raw Ungraded Coin, AU

Buffalo Nickels 1913-1938 Obverse: Indigenous Man Head facing Right with Braid and Two Feathers Reverse: Buffalo Facing Left Incuse Mound designed to Protect the Words Five Cents from Wear Buffalo Nickels Type 1 (1913) The Buffalo Nickel is one of the most iconic designs in U.S. numismatics.
Platform Logo $74.99
1931-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65 Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65

1931-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65
Platform Logo $350.00
1931-S 5C Buffalo Nickel (75021) Cover

1931-S 5C Buffalo Nickel (75021)

The seller is located in Ashburn and has a 100.0% positive feedback rate.
Platform Logo $19.99
1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5c ICG EF45 XF45 - Clipped Planchet Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5c ICG EF45 XF45 - Clipped Planchet

1931-S Buffalo Nickel 5c ICG EF45 XF45 - Clipped Planchet
Platform Logo $60.00
1931S Buffalo Nickel XF Cover

1931S Buffalo Nickel XF

1931S Buffalo Nickel XF. Attractive better date coin with full hair detail and sharp horn on buffalo. Pleasing color. Please add $3.99 shipping.58F
Platform Logo $29.99
Original Low Mintage 1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5¢ FREE SHIPPING!! JS32MI Cover

Original Low Mintage 1931-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5¢ FREE SHIPPING!! JS32MI

SWEETWATERCOIN is a leading provider of nice collectible coins. Coins removed from their original holders are considered.
Platform Logo $19.95
#4 nicer "Fine++" low mintage 1931 S Buffalo Head Nickel Cover

#4 nicer "Fine++" low mintage 1931 S Buffalo Head Nickel

The seller is located in Woodburn and has a 100.0% positive feedback rate.
Platform Logo $18.00
1931-S Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Mint USA 5c -Key Date -ACTUAL PHOTOS LX4 Cover

1931-S Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Mint USA 5c -Key Date -ACTUAL PHOTOS LX4

Struck in 1931 During the Great Depression. The Buffalo nickel or Indian Head nickel is a copper-nickel five-cent piece that was struck by the United States Mint from 1913 to 1938. Five denominations of US coins received new designs between 1907 and 1919 as part of a drive to beautify the coinage.
Platform Logo $24.67
1931 S BUFFALO NICKEL CHOICE VF NICE OLD COIN #205 Cover

1931 S BUFFALO NICKEL CHOICE VF NICE OLD COIN #205

SEE PICTURES FOR ACTUAL COIN.
Platform Logo $19.99
Old US Coins 1931 S Keydate 5C Buffalo Five Cents Nickel Cover

Old US Coins 1931 S Keydate 5C Buffalo Five Cents Nickel

1931 S Keydate 5C BUFFALO Nickel. A 1931 S 5 CENTS BUFFALO NICKEL COIN SHOWN IN THE PICTURES IS THE ONE YOU WILL RECEIVE!
Platform Logo $39.95
1931 S Indian Buffalo NGC MS-66+ Cover

1931 S Indian Buffalo NGC MS-66+

Bob Paul Rare Coins is one of the leading numismatic firms in the country. Many of the certified coins are personally sent for certification to PCGS and NGC by Bob, himself. Many coins are individually selected for their eye appeal, scarcity, as well as, affordability for the typical collector.
Platform Logo $1977.50
1931 s Buffalo Head Nickel, beautiful original unc. nickel in a very high grade Cover

1931 s Buffalo Head Nickel, beautiful original unc. nickel in a very high grade

You will receive the coin pictured.
Platform Logo $109.00

Related Searches

1931 D Mercury Dimes thumbnail
1931 D Mercury Dimes

761 products
1931 Mercury Dimes thumbnail
1931 Mercury Dimes

760 products
1931 S Buffalo Nickels thumbnail
1931 S Buffalo Nickels

749 products
1931 P Mercury Dimes thumbnail
1931 P Mercury Dimes

761 products
1931 Lincoln Wheat Small Cents thumbnail
1931 Lincoln Wheat Small Cents

2,167 products
1931 S Mercury Dimes thumbnail
1931 S Mercury Dimes

761 products